In which of the following examples is utilitarianism absent?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: The prompt asks in which example utilitarianism is absent. Here are the options to evaluate:
Option A: Moving production operations to other countries, so that the company remains competitive.
Option B: Raising prices to increase profitability.
Option C: Laying off a small number of employees so that the larger number of workers can continue to work full-time jobs.
Option D: Using impartial means to equitably distribute benefits and costs.
Option E: Discontinuing products with questionable effects on health.

Now, let’s analyze each option and discuss why utilitarianism might or might not be at play.

Option A — Moving production to another country to stay competitive:
- This action is primarily about corporate strategy and competitive positioning. A utilitarian assessment would require weighing overall net happiness or welfare changes resulting from the move, including impacts on employees, customers, suppliers, and communities in both the origin and destination. While it could align with utilitarian goals if it maximizes overall welfare (e.g., lower prices, greater long-term job stability, or societal benefits from a stronger company), it could also cause harms (job losses or economic decline in the home country). The key point is that utilitarianism is present only if the action is justified by maximizing overall welfare; the description alone does not guarantee this outcome. The option’s emphasis on competitiveness does not inherently illustrate a utilitarian calculation. In this sense, whether utilitarianism is present depends on the underlying welfare calculations, but the prompt’s framing suggests the action is not explicitly justified by a utilitarian calculus.

Option B — Raising prices to increase profitability:
- This could be justified under utilitarian reasoning if the increased profits are used to benefit a greater number of people (e.g., reinvestment leading to more jobs, improved products, or lower prices elsewhere through cross-subsidization). However, it can also harm consumers by reducing consumer surplus and welfare, especially if price increases are excessive or exploit a monopoly. The utilitarian assessment hinges on whether the net effect on overall welfare (sum of happiness, satisfaction, health, and wellbeing) is positive or negative. Since the option presents only a price increase geared toward profitability, without explicit welfare justification, it does not inherently demonstrate utilitarianism; it depends on the broader consequences.

Option C — Laying off a small number of employees so that the larger number of workers can continue to work full-time jobs:
- This is a classic utilitarian-aligned justification in many analyses: a minority of job losses to preserve employment and stability for a larger group, potentially maximizing net happiness and welfare. If the layoff decision improves overall welfare (e.g., preventing company collapse, preserving livelihoods for many, maintaining production capacity), it can be considered utilitarian. This option tends to fit a consequentialist calculation focused on outcomes for the many versus the few.

Option D — Using impartial means to equitably distribute benefits and costs:
- Impartial distribution of benefits and costs aligns strongly with utilitarian and egalitarian perspectives, since utilitarianism seeks to maximize overall welfare and often assumes impartial consideration of individuals’ welfare. This option reflects a core utilitarian principle of treating interests without bias in the distribution process, which is consistent with utilitarian reasoning.

Option E — Discontinuing products with questionable effects on health:
- This action also aligns with utilitarian concerns if discontinuation reduces harm and increases overall welfare (e.g., protecting health, reducing risk, avoiding negative consequences for consumers). It demonstrates a precautionary and welfare-maximizing approach, which fits utilitarian logic.

Summary of reasoning for each option:
- A: The statement describes a strategic corporate move. Its utilitarian status depends on whether the move results in a net increase in overall welfare; the prompt does not specify such calculations, so it is not inherently utilitarian.
- B: A price increase could harm consumers or help welfare depending on broader effects; lacking explicit welfare justification, it is not definitively utilitarian.
- C: Laying off a minority to protect a larger group can reflect utilitarian reasoning by maximizing total welfare, making this option compatible with utilitarianism in many analyses.
- D: Impartial distribution of benefits and costs fits utilitarian and related ethical theories, reflecting fair consideration of all affected individuals.
- E: Discontinuing harmful products aligns with welfare and harm-reduction aims, consistent with utilitarian goals.

Conclusion note (as requested, this section is not to reveal the correct option first): The evaluation shows that several options can align with utilitarian reasoning under different welfare calculations (C, D, E). However, based on the prompt’s given answer key, option A is indicated as the one where utilitarianism is absent, suggesting that, in this specific framing, moving production for competitiveness is presented as not inherently utilitarian without explicit welfare justification.

In which of the following examples is utilitarianism absent?单项选择题

类似问题

The “Greatest Happiness Principle” is a core concept of which ethical theory?

The utilitarian rule states that an ethical decision is one that

One of the drawbacks to utilitarian method of ethical reasoning is that:

Which ethical theory represents a focus on the consequences of an action?

Which of the following describes an ethical framework based on achieving the best outcome for the greatest number of people?

What is the position of Utilitarianism?

Who is considered the founder of utilitarianism?

What is the central idea behind utilitarianism?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单