What role does Rousseau assign to pity in the absence of law?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Rousseau treats pity (pitié) as a primary natural sentiment that restrains harmful action when formal law and civil institutions are absent.

1. Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- State of nature: Rousseau describes humans before civil society as guided by natural sentiments rather than laws.
- Pity (pitié): for Rousseau, an innate compassionate feeling that inclines us not to cause suffering to others.
- Moral authority: in Rousseau’s account, natural sentiments can ground rudimentary moral restraints, but they differ from the obligations created by social contract and law.

2. Step-by-step reasoning
- In the state of nature humans lack legal institutions and codified duties.
- Rousseau identifies pity as a natural check on aggression and exploitation: it makes us reluctant to harm others because we feel their suffering.
- Because pity is a feeling rather than a legal rule, it operates intermittently and non-systematically; it restrains some harmful acts but does not produce enforceable obligations or a full moral/legal code.
- Therefore pity functions as a moral restraint that is original and natural but weaker than law-based morality.

3. Intermediate logical steps (explicit)
- Premise: No law → no formal sanctions or duties.
- Premise: Humans have natural sentiments (self-preservation and pity).
- Inference: Pity produces compassionate restraint but lacks enforcement mechanisms.
- Conclusion: Pity = natural but weaker moral force.

4. Why the correct answer is correct
- The wording “weaker but more natural form of morality” captures both that pity is innate (more natural) and that it lacks the strength, universality, and enforceability of law or civil morality (weaker). This matches Rousseau’s explicit claim that pity is the original, natural limitation on injustice prior to social institutions.

5. Why other options are incorrect
- a) “A perfected system of voluntary obligation”: incorrect because pity is not a perfected, systematic obligation—it is an affective restraint.
- b) “None of these answers”: incorrect because Rousseau clearly assigns a role to pity.
- c) “A violent check on exploitative behavior”: incorrect—pity restrains violence; it is not itself violent.
- e) “A transformative mode of rational compassion”: incorrect because pity is affective and pre-rational, not primarily a rational mode.

6. Conclusion confirming the answer
Therefore the correct answer is d) A weaker but more natural form of morality, which matches the provided answer.

What role does Rousseau assign to pity in the absence of law?单项选择题

类似问题

According to Rousseau, the Savagery of Neoliberalism and Technology Principle holds that the further human life is absorbed into digital systems of commerce, the more its moral instincts for compassion grow through resistance to abstraction. Which one of his quotes best supports this principle?

Which of the following would Mill most likely reject as a valid explanation for why we care so strongly about justice?

Match the following quote to the moral concept it best illustrates in Nietzsche’s genealogy: “The noble type of man experiences itself as value-creating; it does not need approval...”

Which of the following best captures Mill’s account of the internal sanction that gives morality its binding authority?

Which of the following best reflects Mill’s view on when self-sacrifice is morally justified?

Which of the following best reflects a condition Nietzsche associates with weakness that disguises itself as moral insight?

In the topic of Ethics, Utilitarianism are decisions made exclusively based on their outcomes and

Ethics refers to the study of the ______________ that we all have to make in our lives

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单