Stare Decisis means:

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Stare decisis literally means "to stand by things decided" and refers to the doctrine that prior judicial decisions (precedents) guide future cases. The key knowledge points: (1) ratio decidendi (the legal principle or reason for the decision) is the binding element of a precedent; (2) obiter dicta (comments made incidentally) are persuasive but not binding; (3) the hierarchical court structure: lower courts are bound by decisions of higher courts (vertical stare decisis), and courts may follow their own past decisions (horizontal stare decisis) but with some flexibility; (4) precedents can be followed, distinguished, or overruled.

Step-by-step reasoning:
1. Identify whether a prior decision contains a ratio decidendi: only that part is binding on later courts.
2. Determine court hierarchy: if the earlier decision came from a higher court, a lower court is normally bound.
3. Compare facts: if the material facts of the new case differ significantly from the earlier case, a court can distinguish the earlier decision and decline to apply its ratio.
4. If the prior decision is clearly wrong or circumstances justify change, a higher court may overrule it (not a routine outcome).

Why the correct option is right: it states that a judge's earlier decision is binding unless it can be distinguished based on the facts — this captures the essential operation of stare decisis: binding effect of ratio, subject to being distinguished when the factual matrix is materially different. Distinguishing is the standard lawful method to avoid following precedent without overruling it.

Why the other options are incorrect:
- "Always binding" is wrong because precedents can be distinguished or overruled; they are not absolutely binding in all circumstances.
- "Binding unless ... distinguished based on new evidence" is imprecise: it’s the factual differences (the case’s material facts), not mere "new evidence" after judgment, that allow a court to distinguish precedent. New evidence might affect proceedings but does not change the doctrine.

Conclusion: The correct answer is "The decision of a judge in a previous case is binding unless it can be distinguished based on the facts," which matches the provided answer.

Stare Decisis means:单项选择题

类似问题

Question at position 9 In legal terms, "Precedent" refers to:The person who brings the case to courtThe process of selecting new Supreme Court JusticesA previous court decision that serves as a rule or guide for similar cases in the futureA law that has been vetoed by the President

Which of these helps to provide predictability and consistency to judicial decisions?

Cases that serve as a basis for decisions by judges in other courts are known as:

Stare decisis is the doctrine of ________.

A project has a required return of 12.6 percent, an initial cash outflow of $42,100, and cash inflows of $16,500 in Year 1, $11,700 in Year 2, and $10,400 in Year 4. What is the net present value?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单