Embryo screening to determine if a genetic disorder such as infantile Tay Sachs disease (https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/14348-tay-sachs-disease
Links to an external site.
) is present would be considered by most people as a form of eugenics.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Interpreting the statement requires unpacking what is meant by embryo screening and the term eugenics.
Option 1: True. Some people define eugenics as any attempt to influence the genetic makeup of a population to reduce burdens of genetic disease. Under that broader definition, embryo screening to detect disorders like infantile Tay-Sachs could be viewed as eugenics because it aims to prevent the birth of affected individuals, thereby shaping the genetic composition of future generations. Advocates who take this view point to the selection aspect of screening as aligning with eugenic goals, even if framed in medical terms.
Option 2: False. Others distinguish eugenics as a coordinated policy or movement with coercive or systemic aims to ‘improve’ the gene pool, often involving forced or targeted genetic selection and broader social agendas. From this narrower, historical, policy-oriented definition, routine or voluntary embryo screening performed in medical contexts to prevent suffering is typically framed as preventive medicine, genetic counseling, or reproductive autonomy rather than eugenics. In this sense, embryo screening can be seen as a clinical tool for informed decision-making rather than a eugenic program.
Additional nuance: many contemporary discussions emphasize consent, autonomy, and the non-coercive nature of modern genetic testing, which challenges simplistic labels. Some ethicists argue that even voluntary screening can have eugenic-style implications if societal pressures or norms push individuals toward particular reproductive choices, but the core clinical practice itself is usually categorized separately from eugenics as a distinct medical-ethical activity.
Therefore, the reasoning hinges on which definition of eugenics is being applied and how strictly one distinguishes clinical screening from population-level eugenic policy. If one uses a broad, movement-based definition, the statement could be considered true; if one uses a narrow, policy-oriented definition, the statement could be considered false.

Embryo screening to determine if a genetic disorder such as infantile Tay Sachs disease (https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/14348-tay-sachs-disease Links to an external site. ) is present would be considered by most people as a form of eugenics.判断题

类似问题

In the United States, most newborns undergo a test for primary congenital hypothyroidism, a condition where people are unable to produce enough thyroid hormone. On a nationwide basis, this is an example of

What are we doing or using in LP26?

You mutagenize E. coli with UV light and then plate it onto XGAL medium. (Cells that can ferment lactose will appear blue, while those that cannot will appear white). This is an example of a

Which of the following answers are common genetic screening strategies in Drosophila melanogaster? Mark all that apply

In the zebrafish model, what is the value of gynogenetic haploid screening?

In zebrafish, what is the advantage of gynogenetic haploid screening?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单