General Motors (GM) will invest $625mn in a lithium mine in Nevada. GM will enter into a joint venture with Lithium Americas to develop the Thacker Pass mine in Nevada. GM will be the minority partner with 38% stake in the project, while Lithium Americas will have a 62% stake. The mine is expected to produce enough of the metal to supply 800,000 electric vehicles. The partnership gives GM the exclusive rights to the first stage of lithium production at Thacker Pass for 20 years. This means that GM may potentially have a competitive advantage based on:单项选择题
A
Causal ambiguity
B
Path dependency
C
Physical uniqueness
D
Economies of scale

Question

General Motors (GM) will invest $625mn in a lithium mine in Nevada. GM will enter into a joint venture with Lithium Americas to develop the Thacker Pass mine in Nevada. GM will be the minority partner with 38% stake in the project, while Lithium Americas will have a 62% stake. The mine is expected to produce enough of the metal to supply 800,000 electric vehicles. The partnership gives GM the exclusive rights to the first stage of lithium production at Thacker Pass for 20 years. This means that GM may potentially have a competitive advantage based on:单项选择题

A

Causal ambiguity

B

Path dependency

C

Physical uniqueness

D

Economies of scale

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Exclusive control of a scarce input—GM’s exclusive rights to the first stage of lithium production at Thacker Pass for 20 years—constitutes physical uniqueness because it grants access to a tangible, hard-to-replicate resource that rivals cannot obtain.

1) Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- Resource-Based View (RBV): sustainable competitive advantage arises from valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable resources.
- Physical uniqueness: ownership or exclusive access to tangible assets (natural resources, locations, inputs) that competitors cannot easily replicate.
- Other concepts (for contrast): economies of scale (cost advantages from larger production), path dependency (advantages from historical investments/trajectories), causal ambiguity (competitors cannot understand why a firm is successful).

2) Step-by-step reasoning
- GM secures exclusive rights to the first stage of lithium production at Thacker Pass for 20 years.
- Lithium is a critical, scarce input for EV batteries; the mine can supply enough metal for 800,000 EVs.
- Exclusive access means competitors cannot source that specific output stream from Thacker Pass for two decades.
- Under RBV, exclusive ownership/access to a scarce, valuable input is rare and difficult for rivals to imitate, producing a competitive advantage.

3) Intermediate steps / simple figures
- Stakeholding: GM is a 38% JV partner (minority) vs Lithium Americas 62% (majority) — but the strategic advantage cited arises from exclusive production rights, not from majority ownership.
- Output scale: mine capacity cited as sufficient for 800,000 EVs — illustrates the economic significance of the resource.

4) Why the correct answer is correct
- The core advantage is derived from a tangible, exclusive resource (right to first-stage lithium production). That is the textbook definition of physical uniqueness: control over a scarce physical input that competitors cannot access, leading to potential cost, supply security, or differentiation advantages.

5) Why other options are incorrect
- Economies of scale: refers to lower unit costs as production volume rises; GM’s advantage arises from exclusivity of resource, not from scale-driven cost curves.
- Path dependency: implies advantage from historical investments or processes accumulated over time; this deal grants exclusive access now, not an historical path.
- Causal ambiguity: concerns rivals’ inability to identify the source of advantage (tacit knowledge); here the source is explicit and observable—exclusive physical rights—so it is not ambiguous.

6) Conclusion
The partnership’s exclusive, long-term rights to Thacker Pass lithium represent physical uniqueness. Final answer: Physical uniqueness.

类似问题

Question at position 27 Firm X possesses valuable resources that are neither rare nor costly to imitate. What is the most likely outcome for Firm X?sustained competitive advantagecompetitive paritycompetitive disadvantagetemporary advantage

Over time, a resource of the Fast & Furious movies included off screen drama. This resource is: Access PDF Here: Click to open: Download Fast & Furious & Way Less Expensive. A Star Film Franchise Gets a Reality Check. - WSJ.pdf Manage Alternates

Over time, the resources of the Fast & Furious movies changed to include , which are __. Access PDF Here: Click to open: Download Fast & Furious & Way Less Expensive. A Star Film Franchise Gets a Reality Check. - WSJ.pdf Manage Alternates

Competitive parity exists when a resource is:

A firm’s resource is rare because demand for it is low. Which conclusion best reflects RBV logic?

According to the resource-based view, there is a growing trend showing that a firm’s competitive advantage often stems from its

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单