Son: Wow, Dad, it's really hard to make a living on my salary.

Father: Consider yourself lucky, son. Why? When I was your age, I only made $40 a week.

The above is a good example of _______________ fallacy.

Question

Son: Wow, Dad, it's really hard to make a living on my salary.

Father: Consider yourself lucky, son. Why? When I was your age, I only made $40 a week.

The above is a good example of _______________ fallacy.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question and options restated: The dialogue presents a father commenting on his past earnings to address his son's complaint about making a living on a salary. The task is to identify which fallacy this exemplifies.
Option 1: ad hominem
This would involve attacking the person rather than addressing the argument. In the exchange, there is no personal attack on the son or father; the focus shifts to past income rather than criticizing character, so this option mischaracterizes the move.
Option 2: appeal to pity
An appeal to pity tries to evoke sympathy to win acceptance of a claim. Here, the father’s statement about his own past earnings does not attempt to elicit pity to justify a conclusion about the son’s salary; it’s more about diverting attention than appealing for sympathy, so this is not a precise fit.
Option 3: red herring
A red herring is a distraction that steers the conversation away from the central issue. The son complains salary is hard to live on, and the father responds by recalling a different, unrelated benchmark (his own past pay) to imply the issue is less serious or to shift focus. This move effectively distracts from evaluating the son’s current financial situation.
Option 4: scare tactics
Scare tactics rely on fear to influence belief or behavior. There is no attempt to incite fear or threaten negative outcomes in this exchange, so this option does not apply.
Further observations: The key feature of a red herring is introducing information that's tangential to the original argument (the son’s salary and living standard) to derail the discussion. The other fallacies require other patterns—personal attack, pity-based appeal, or fear-based intimidation—which aren’t evident here. The father’s remark serves to derail the topic rather than directly argue for or against a point about the son’s salary, aligning best with the red herring structure.

Son: Wow, Dad, it's really hard to make a living on my salary. Father: Consider yourself lucky, son. Why? When I was your age, I only made $40 a week. The above is a good example of _______________ fallacy.单项选择题

类似问题

A politician argues: “We must implement my economic plan. If we don’t, our nation will fall into a terrible depression and millions will suffer.” This statement primarily represents:

A politician argues: “We must implement my economic plan. If we don’t, our nation will fall into a terrible depression and millions will suffer.” This statement primarily represents:

People should not wear fur coats because it’s the wrong thing to do. Football is fun to watch because it’s such an enjoyable game.

Question at position 38 red herringstrawmanad hominemhasty generalizationjumping into conclusions

Question at position 23 ad hominemstrawmanhasty generalizationred herringappeal to emotion

Which of the following best identifies a misuse of evidence or logic in the passage?

Question at position 16 appeal to emotionstrawmanad hominemred herringhasty generalization

"In advocating expanded unemployment benefits, someone observed that 'All the European countries have higher unemployment rates than we do but also stronger support systems for the unemployed.' " This argument supporting expanded unemployment benefits can best be countered by arguing that

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单