Comparing the effects of import tariff and export subsidy on an economy, we may summarize that … . Select one – the most appropriate answer to fill in the space above.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: The prompt asks to compare the effects of an import tariff and an export subsidy on an economy and to select the most appropriate statement.
Option 1: 'They have different impact, however they both have positive consequences for an economy.' This is overly optimistic and misleading: tariffs and subsidies typically create distortions, may reduce welfare, and rarely have universally positive consequences; claiming they have positive effects for all economies ignores distributional and efficiency losses.
Option 2: 'They influence an economy in different ways: tariff produces the generally positive effect, while subsidy’s impact is negative.' This is incorrect in implying tariffs generally have a positive effect; most analyses emphasize deadweight losses from tariffs, terms-of-trade effects, and potential retaliation, rather than a clear positive outcome. Subsidies, including export subsidies, also create distortions and can have negative consequences; the blanket claim of tariff positivity is not supported.
Option 3: 'They both have similar impact, but the overall negative effect of tariff is expected to be higher.' This option argues that tariffs have a higher negative impact than subsidies. While both instruments generate distortions, this statement asserts tariffs are more harmful, which is not universally true and depends on context; many analyses show export subsidies can provoke even larger misallocations and global welfare losses, so this is an unlikely universal claim.
Option 4: 'No correct answer.' This would be chosen if none of the statements reasonably captured the comparison; however, there is a statement that aligns with common economic intuition about subsidy's negative effects compared to tariffs in terms of broader distortions, so declaring no correct answer would be inappropriate here.
Option 5: 'They both have similar impact, but the overall negative effect of subsidy is expected to be higher.' This option asserts that both instruments distort economies in similar ways (both create inefficiencies and welfare losses), but suggests that export subsidies tend to generate larger negative consequences overall due to global market distortions, budget costs, and potential retaliation; this aligns with standard comparative-trade theory that subsidies to exports can impose substantial distortions and welfare costs, often exceeding those of tariffs in magnitude in many contexts.
In summary, options 1 and 2 make overly positive or context-insensitive claims about tariffs, option 3 makes an unsubstantiated claim that tariffs are more harmful, option 4 denies any correct statement despite a plausible comparative claim, and option 5 presents a balanced view recognizing both similarity in distortion and the relatively larger negative impact of subsidies, which corresponds to the commonly discussed outcome in trade-misallocation analyses.

Comparing the effects of import tariff and export subsidy on an economy, we may summarize that … . Select one – the most appropriate answer to fill in the space above.单项选择题

类似问题

A spice, found to cure many ailments, is only found in a small part of Asia. The region has begun exporting the spice around the world. This shows the

Which of the following is NOT true about the trade relationship between two countries, such as China and the U.S.?

Which of the following are reasons to trade with the rest of the world? Select all that apply.

International trade in goods and services has increased over the last 50 years because of ______. Select all that apply.

Question at position 50 Which one of the following is NOT one of the functions of the World Trade Organization?Monitoring trade policiesHelping to combat emergencies, such as the worldwide pandemicProviding aid for developing countriesHelping to resolve trade disputesClear my selection

Question at position 21 An import can only occur inside the borders of your home country and an export can only occur outside the borders of your home countryTrueFalse

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单