You are concerned that the Immigration Officer who is deciding your client's visa application is biased. You cannot prove they are biased but their decision-making leads you to suspect they are biased. Question: Which specific Immigration Instruction is relevant to this situation? (1 mark)简答题
登录即可查看完整答案
我们收录了全球超50000道真实原题与详细解析,现在登录,立即获得答案。

Question

You are concerned that the Immigration Officer who is deciding your client's visa application is biased. You cannot prove they are biased but their decision-making leads you to suspect they are biased. Question: Which specific Immigration Instruction is relevant to this situation? (1 mark)简答题

登录即可查看完整答案

我们收录了全球超50000道真实原题与详细解析,现在登录,立即获得答案。

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

A1.10.b is the specific Immigration Instruction that applies here because it deals with bias, conflicts of interest and the appearance of partiality in decision‑making.

Relevant knowledge points and concepts:
- Administrative fairness requires not only absence of actual bias but also avoidance of circumstances that give rise to a reasonable suspicion of bias (apparent bias).
- Immigration Instructions contain discrete provisions on decision‑maker conduct, conflicts of interest and recusal procedures; the subsection A1.10.b is the one addressing these issues.
- When a client’s representative reasonably suspects bias (even without proof), the correct procedural step is to rely on the instruction that governs impartiality and the process for addressing such concerns.

Step‑by‑step reasoning:
1. The fact pattern: you suspect the deciding Immigration Officer is biased but cannot prove it. That raises the issue of apparent bias or potential conflict of interest, not the substantive visa criteria.
2. Identify which Instruction governs decision‑maker impartiality rather than eligibility criteria. That Instruction is A1.10.b.
3. Apply A1.10.b: it describes the standards for impartiality and the mechanisms to address perceived bias (for example, raising the concern through supervisory channels, requesting reassignment or following the internal complaint/recusal process set out in the Instruction).
4. Because the concern is about the officer’s impartiality, not about evidentiary sufficiency or statutory eligibility, the A1.10.b provision is the directly relevant instruction.

Why the correct answer is correct:
- A1.10.b specifically addresses bias and the appearance of bias by decision‑makers; therefore it is the instruction to consult when suspicion of bias exists.

Why other instructions are not correct:
- Other Immigration Instructions focus on substantive assessment of visa criteria, documentation, or procedural fairness generally, but they do not specifically set out duties and procedures relating to bias/recusal the way A1.10.b does.

Conclusion:
The correct and relevant Immigration Instruction for a suspected (but unproven) bias by an Immigration Officer is A1.10.b. This matches the provided answer.

You are concerned that the Immigration Officer who is deciding your client's visa application is biased. You cannot prove they are biased but their decision-making leads you to suspect they are biased. Question: Which specific Immigration Instruction is relevant to this situation? (1 mark)简答题

类似问题

Which specific Immigration Instruction states that a practical step toward achieving fairness and natural justice is to distinguish fact from rumour, opinion, allegation or assumption? (1 mark)

Which statement is correct about the definition of potentially prejudicial information for applicants outside of New Zealand? (1 mark)

Which statement is NOT correct about the definition of potentially prejudicial information for applicants in New Zealand? (1 mark)

Which specific Immigration Instruction states that a practical step toward achieving fairness and natural justice is to distinguish fact from rumour, opinion, allegation or assumption? (1 mark)

Which of the following options is NOT a function of Immigration New Zealand: (1 mark)

Which statement is correct about the definition of potentially prejudicial information for applicants outside of New Zealand? (1 mark)

Which statement is NOT correct about the definition of potentially prejudicial information for applicants in New Zealand? (1 mark)

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单