True/False: Suppose we build a Huffman tree T for a character set C with frequency count f. Let c in C be the character with lowest frequency, that is f(c)

Question

True/False: Suppose we build a Huffman tree T for a character set C with frequency count f. Let c in C be the character with lowest frequency, that is f(c) < f(d) for all d in C-c. Then the depthT(c) ≥ depthT(d) for all d in C.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

In an optimal Huffman code, symbols with smaller frequencies cannot occupy strictly shallower leaves than higher-frequency symbols because that would allow a cost-reducing swap.

1) Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- A Huffman tree minimizes the weighted external path length: cost = Σ_x f(x) · depth(x).
- An optimal prefix code has the property that if a symbol a has frequency ≤ b, there exists an optimal tree with depth(a) ≥ depth(b). The usual proof uses an exchange (swap) argument.
- The Huffman greedy algorithm always merges the two least-frequency nodes first, which tends to push low-frequency symbols to larger depth.

2) Complete reasoning process (step by step)
Assume T is an optimal Huffman tree for frequency function f, and c is the unique least-frequency symbol with f(c) < f(d) for every other d. Suppose, for contradiction, that there exists some d with depth(c) < depth(d) (i.e., c is strictly shallower than d).

3) Calculation and intermediate steps
Consider a new tree T' formed by swapping the positions (leaf locations) of c and d in T. All other leaves keep the same depths. The cost change Δ = cost(T') − cost(T) equals
Δ = f(c)·depth(d) + f(d)·depth(c) − [f(c)·depth(c) + f(d)·depth(d)]
   = (f(c) − f(d)) · (depth(d) − depth(c)).

Because f(c) − f(d) < 0 (f(c) < f(d)) and depth(d) − depth(c) > 0 by assumption, their product Δ is negative. So cost(T') < cost(T), contradicting optimality of T.

4) Why the correct answer is correct
This contradiction shows the assumption depth(c) < depth(d) cannot hold. Therefore depth(c) ≥ depth(d) for every d in C. The result follows directly from the weighted-sum optimality and the exchange argument.

5) Why the other option (False) is incorrect
Claiming False would assert there exists an optimal Huffman tree where the unique least-frequency symbol is strictly shallower than some higher-frequency symbol; the swap argument above demonstrates such a configuration cannot be optimal because swapping reduces total cost.

6) Conclusion
Thus the statement is True, which matches the provided answer.

True/False: Suppose we build a Huffman tree T for a character set C with frequency count f. Let c in C be the character with lowest frequency, that is f(c) < f(d) for all d in C-c. Then the depthT(c) ≥ depthT(d) for all d in C.判断题

类似问题

Given the Huffman tree below, how many bits are needed to encode "arc"? Please type an integer.

True/False: Suppose we build a Huffman tree T for a character set C with frequency count f. Let c in C be the character with highest frequency, that is f(c) > f(d) for all d in C-c. Then the depthT(c) ≤ depthT(d) for all d in C.

When evaluating a new project, firms should include in the projected cash flows all of the following EXCEPT:

Provide the best rationale for what's wrong with supply chains today?

What is Blockchain and how is it relevant to supply chain management?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单