Question at position 35 All the statements are true. Which one gives the primary reason why the surface of Venus today is some 450ºC hotter than the surface of Earth? Venus is only about 73% as far from the Sun as Earth.Venus has a much higher reflectivity than Earth.Venus has a much stronger greenhouse effect than Earth.Venus has a higher atmospheric pressure than Earth.Venus lacks a magnetic field generated by its core.Clear my selection

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Venus’s extreme heat is dominated by its runaway greenhouse effect: a very dense CO2 atmosphere traps outgoing infrared radiation so strongly that the surface temperature reaches roughly 450°C.

1) Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- Planetary equilibrium temperature (Teq) from absorbed sunlight: Teq = [S(1 − A)/(4σ)]^0.25, where S is solar flux at the orbit, A is albedo, σ is Stefan–Boltzmann constant.
- Greenhouse effect: an atmosphere transparent to sunlight but opaque to infrared raises surface temperature above Teq by trapping outgoing thermal radiation.
- Albedo, orbital distance, atmospheric composition and pressure influence Teq and greenhouse strength; a magnetic field does not directly set surface temperature.

2) Step-by-step reasoning and calculations
- Venus orbits at ~0.73 AU, so the incident solar flux scales as 1/(0.73^2).
  1/(0.73^2) = 1/(0.5329) ≈ 1.876 → Venus receives ≈1.876× the solar flux Earth gets.
- However, Venus’s cloud-covered atmosphere has very high albedo A ≈ 0.77 (Earth’s ≈0.30), so much incoming energy is reflected.
- Compare effective temperatures using the factor f = [ (1.876) * (1 − 0.77)/(1 − 0.30) ]^0.25:
  (1 − 0.77) = 0.23; (1 − 0.30) = 0.70.
  Multiply: 1.876 * (0.23/0.70) = 1.876 * 0.32857 ≈ 0.616.
  f = 0.616^0.25 = exp(0.25 * ln 0.616) ≈ exp(0.25 * −0.484) ≈ exp(−0.121) ≈ 0.886.
- Earth’s effective temperature ≈ 255 K, so Venus’s effective (no-greenhouse) ≈ 0.886 * 255 ≈ 226 K (~ −47°C). This is far below the observed surface temperature (~723–737 K, i.e., ~450°C).
- The enormous difference (surface ~ 450°C vs effective ~ −47°C) is due to the greenhouse effect of a dense CO2 atmosphere, which raises surface temperature by hundreds of kelvins.

3) Intermediate steps shown above (flux ratio, albedo correction, Teq scaling).

4) Why the correct answer is correct
- The calculations show that without greenhouse trapping, Venus would be much colder than it is; the greenhouse effect is the mechanism that traps thermal infrared and elevates surface temperature to ~450°C. The composition (mostly CO2) and optical depth of Venus’s atmosphere produce this runaway greenhouse.

5) Why other options are incorrect
- “Only 73% as far” (closer orbit): increases incident flux but, after accounting for Venus’s high albedo, would raise Teq only modestly (≈17% higher than Earth’s Teq), not by hundreds of K.
- “Higher reflectivity”: actually reduces absorbed sunlight and would make Venus cooler if greenhouse were absent.
- “Higher atmospheric pressure”: high pressure is associated with the massive atmosphere but by itself does not create the trapped IR; pressure is a consequence of the large CO2 mass that causes the greenhouse effect.
- “Lacks a magnetic field”: this affects atmospheric escape over geologic time scales, not the immediate surface temperature.

6) Conclusion
The dominant reason for Venus’s ~450°C surface temperature is that Venus has a much stronger greenhouse effect than Earth, matching the provided correct answer.

类似问题

Which of the following statements concerning greenhouse warming or climate change is FALSE?

There are many greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4). and vaporized water (H2O). These and other greenhouse gases warm the Earth primarily by:

Carbon dioxide, CO2, is an important greenhouse gas. Greenhouse gases warm the Earth primarily by:

What property makes a gas a greenhouse gas?

Regarding the Earth's greenhouse effect and its implications for climate change, which statement is most accurate?

Increased heat from the runaway greenhouse effect evaporates oceans, producing more greenhouse heating. This happened to _ and might happen to _ someday.

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单