Two samples from the same population both have M = 84 and s2 = 20, but one sample has n = 10 and the other has n = 20 scores. Both samples are used to evaluate a hypothesis stating that μ = 80 and to compute Cohen’s d. How will the outcomes for the two samples compare?

Question

​Two samples from the same population both have M = 84 and s2 = 20, but one sample has n = 10 and the other has n = 20 scores. Both samples are used to evaluate a hypothesis stating that μ = 80 and to compute Cohen’s d. How will the outcomes for the two samples compare?

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

When comparing two samples from the same population with the same reported statistics, it helps to separate the effect size from the test statistic.

First, consider Cohen’s d. It is computed as (Xbar − μ0) / s, where s is the standard deviation (the square root of the variance). Here Xbar = 84, μ0 = 80, and s^2 = 20, so s = sqrt(20) ≈ 4.472. Thus d ≈ (84 − 80) / 4.472 ≈ 4 / 4.472 ≈ 0.895. Since these values do not depend on sample size n (they rely on the mean difference and the standard deviation), both samples yield essentially the same Cohen’s d value even though their n differs.

Next, turn to hypothesis testing. The test statistic for testing μ = μ0 with known (or estimated) s is t = (Xbar − μ0) / (s / sqrt(n)). Here the numerator (Xbar − μ0) is the same across samples (84 − 80 = 4), and s is also the same (sqrt(20)). However, because the standard error is s / sqrt(n), the sample with larger n (n = 20) has a smaller standard error, leading to a larger absolute t value and thus a greater likelihood of rejecting H0 if the true mean is 80. Conversely, the smaller sample (n = 10) will have a larger standard error and a smaller t value, making rejection less likely.

Therefore, the statement that "the larger sample is more likely to reject the hypothesis" is true, while the claim that "the two samples will have the same value for Cohen’s d" is also true. The reasoning hinges on the distinction between a standardized effect size (Cohen’s d), which is insensitive to n in this setup, and the test statistic (t), which scales with sqrt(n) and thus benefits from a larger sample size.

Two samples from the same population both have M = 84 and s2 = 20, but one sample has n = 10 and the other has n = 20 scores. Both samples are used to evaluate a hypothesis stating that μ = 80 and to compute Cohen’s d. How will the outcomes for the two samples compare?单项选择题

类似问题

A sample is selected from a population with μ = 46, and a treatment is administered to the sample. After treatment, the sample mean is M = 48 with a sample variance of s2 = 16. Based on this information, what is the value of Cohen’s d?

Calculate Cohen's D: Sample Size Group 1 = 19 Sample Size Group 2 = 16 Standard Deviation Group 1 = 4.2 Standard Deviation Group 2 = 5.5 Sample Mean Group 1 = 41.9 Sample Mean Group 2 = 43.5

Calculate Cohen's D: Sample Mean Difference Score (time 1 - time 2) = 1.7 Standard Deviation Difference Scores = 3.2 Sample Size = 39

Please consider the following information: Sample mean (M) = 50 Population mean (µ) = µM = 47 Sample standard deviation (s) = 4 Sample size (N) = 25 Based on this information, compute the effect size measure, Cohen's d. Please include at least two decimal places when reporting your answer.

According to Cohen's guidelines for the effect size measure d, which of the following would be an example of a medium effect size?

Consider the following information used for a one-sample t test: N = 100, µ = 30, s = 20, and M = 33. Based on this information, what is the measure of effect size, Cohen's d, rounded to two decimal places?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单

​Two samples from the same population both have M = 84 and s2 = 20, but one sample has n = 10 and the other has n = 20 scores. Both samples are used to evaluate a hypothesis stating that μ = 80 and to compute Cohen’s d. How will the outcomes for the two samples compare?单项选择题