17. In the following sentence in paragraph A, why does the writer contrast ‘seeds’ with ‘coal, oil or other precious resources’: “This resource is not coal, oil or other precious resources, but seeds.”

The writer wants to show that ‘coal, oil or precious minerals’ are

Question

17.  In the following sentence in paragraph A, why does the writer contrast ‘seeds’ with ‘coal, oil or other precious resources’: “This resource is not coal, oil or other precious resources, but seeds.”

The writer wants to show that ‘coal, oil or precious minerals’ are

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: In the sentence from paragraph A, why does the writer contrast ‘seeds’ with ‘coal, oil or other precious resources’: “This resource is not coal, oil or other precious resources, but seeds.” The writer wants to show that ‘coal, oil or precious minerals’ are

Option 1: not important at all
- This option claims that coal, oil, or precious resources have no importance whatsoever. The contrast in the sentence does not support a claim of total non-importance; the contrast merely signals a shift in what is being highlighted as the resource. Thus, saying they are not important at all goes beyond what the sentence conveys and ignores the nuanced comparison implied by the contrast.

Option 2: as important as seeds
- If coal, oil, or precious resources were described as being as important as seeds, the contrast would imply equivalence in significance. However, the phrase “but seeds” signals a divergence from those resources, suggesting seeds hold a different, likely higher prominence in this context. Therefore this option misreads the intended emphasis in the contrast.

Option 3: more important than seeds
- This would require the writer to present coal, oil, or minerals as surpassing seeds in importance. The sentence, however, presents seeds as the resource being singled out, not as a superior alternative to seeds. The use of “not … but seeds” directs attention toward seeds rather than elevating coal, oil, or minerals above seeds, making this interpretation unlikely.

Option 4: less important than seeds
- Here the claim is that coal, oil, or precious resources are considered less important than seeds within the discussion. The contrastive structure “not coal, oil or other precious resources, but seeds” aligns with presenting seeds as the emphasized resource, thereby implying that the other resources are viewed as less central in this context. This reading fits the signaling effect of the contrast and the ordinary purpose of such a linguistic turn in argument or description.

In summary, the contrast is used to elevate seeds relative to coal, oil, and precious resources by contrasting them directly and signaling that seeds occupy the more important or preferred position in the sentence’s argument. The option that captures this interpretation is the one that states coal, oil, or precious resources are less important than seeds, given the writer’s deliberate pivot to seeds as the focal resource. Overall, the other choices either overstate or misstate the degree of importance, and do not align with the contrastive construction the author uses.

17. In the following sentence in paragraph A, why does the writer contrast ‘seeds’ with ‘coal, oil or other precious resources’: “This resource is not coal, oil or other precious resources, but seeds.” The writer wants to show that ‘coal, oil or precious minerals’ are单项选择题

类似问题

What is the author’s main purpose for writing this text?

Question at position 9 What is the overall purpose of this text?To warn against overuse of social media.To show how Facebook broke the law.To demonstrate the widespread use of social media.To explain how the law relates to social media.

In Paragraph 4, why does the writer describe the economic hardship and difficult living conditions of workers in Europe?

Why does the writer mention generic drugs in paragraph 15?

What does Sinclair suggest about the meatpacking industry's impact on workers' home lives through his descriptions?

What is the overall purpose of this article?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单