TTS: "In fact, Soylent is not designed to completely replace actual food or provide perfect nutrition. Instead, the inventors aimed through Soylent to bring convenience to busy individuals and provide them with a healthier default option than what they were used to."

What is the relationship between the main idea of the preceding paragraph and the main idea of the paragraph that follows this transitional topic sentence?

Question

TTS: "In fact, Soylent is not designed to completely replace actual food or provide perfect nutrition. Instead, the inventors aimed through Soylent to bring convenience to busy individuals and provide them with a healthier default option than what they were used to."

What is the relationship between the main idea of the preceding paragraph and the main idea of the paragraph that follows this transitional topic sentence?

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The transitional sentence functions as a refutation: it acknowledges a potential objection (that Soylent should replace all food or provide perfect nutrition) and then rejects that objection by stating the inventors’ real aim (convenience and a healthier default).

1. Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- Transitional topic sentences can concede a point, qualify a claim, or refute an objection. 
- Signal words like “In fact” often introduce correction or contradiction. 
- A refutation acknowledges an opposing claim and then provides information that undermines or redirects that claim.

2. Step-by-step reasoning
- The sentence concedes a common criticism: “Soylent is not designed to completely replace actual food or provide perfect nutrition.” That is the counter-argument it addresses.
- Immediately after conceding that point it supplies the inventors’ intended purpose: “bring convenience to busy individuals and provide them with a healthier default option.” This shifts the frame from “failure to replace food” to “successful alternative for convenience/health.”
- Because the sentence both acknowledges the opposing claim and supplies an explanation that neutralizes the objection, its rhetorical role is to refute the counter-argument’s implication that Soylent is a failure or irrelevant.

3. Intermediate steps (logical progression)
- Identify the objection (complete replacement/perfect nutrition).
- Identify the corrective claim (intent: convenience and healthier default).
- Determine rhetorical move: corrective claim undermines the objection by showing the criticism misstates the product’s goal.

4. Why the correct answer is correct
- The paragraph following the transitional sentence does not simply add examples or give causes; it directly contradicts the notion that Soylent must replace all food to be valuable. That is the essence of refutation: showing the opposing argument is misplaced or incorrect given the inventors’ aims.

5. Why other possible relationships are incorrect
- Not mere support/elaboration: those would expand the same claim without addressing an opposing view. 
- Not contrast: contrast would set two equally valid opposing ideas; here one is being corrected. 
- Not cause-effect or example: the sentence does not present causation or illustration, but a corrective justification.

6. Conclusion
The paragraph that follows functions as a refutation of the counter-argument about Soylent’s inability to replace food. This matches the provided answer.

类似问题

Causes belong in the Situation and negative effects belong in the Problem.

Which statement best describes the role of section headings?

The chapter compares two versions of a text about competency-based training (CBT).Why was Version B easier to understand than Version A?

Question at position 2 Why is it important for texts of the same genre to have similar structures?To make them more interesting to readTo ensure they belong to the same genre and are easy to understandTo increase their lengthTo make them more difficult to write

6. Research shows that when students read texts aloud, it is easier for them to identify poorly organised Answer Question 6[input] in them.

What is a semantic structure?

What is a semantic structure?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单