What common inferential error discussed in class best describes the following passage:

Analysts trying to explain why some developing countries have grown so much more rapidly than others regularly select a few successful new industrializing countries (NICs) for study, most often Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, Brazil, and Mexico. In all these countries, during the periods of most rapid growth, governments exerted extensive controls over labor and prevented most expressions of worker discontent. Having noted this similarity, analysts argue that the repression, cooptation, discipline, or quiescence of labor contributes to high growth.

Question

What common inferential error discussed in class best describes the following passage:

Analysts trying to explain why some developing countries have grown so much more rapidly than others regularly select a few successful new industrializing countries (NICs) for study, most often Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, Brazil, and Mexico. In all these countries, during the periods of most rapid growth, governments exerted extensive controls over labor and prevented most expressions of worker discontent. Having noted this similarity, analysts argue that the repression, cooptation, discipline, or quiescence of labor contributes to high growth.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: The passage describes analysts selecting a subset of developing countries that had rapid growth (Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, Brazil, and Mexico) and then inferring that government repression of labor contributed to that growth. The task is to identify the common inferential error this illustrates.

Option analysis:
- Selecting on the DV: This option identifies a bias where researchers condition their analysis on cases that exhibit the dependent variable (in this context, rapid growth), and then infer a causal factor (labor repression) from that subset. Because the sample is built around successful outcomes, factors that coincide with those outcomes are mistaken for causes, while many other cases with different outcomes are ignored. This exactly matches the described reasoning: analysts look only at countries with high growth and note a similarity (labor repression), then claim repression contributed to growth.
- Other potential options (not provided in the prompt): If we considered related biases, we might think of post hoc reasoning (after the fact causality), selection bias (sampling bias due to non-random selection), or a focus on correlation without establishing causation. However, those would not capture the specific mechanism described here as precisely as “selecting on the dependent variable,” which is the textbook label for this form of reasoning.

Why the selecting-on-the-DV explanation fits: The analysts deliberately choose cases that have the outcome of interest (rapid growth) and then look for common features among them to explain that outcome. This creates an illusion that those features (government labor repression, control, etc.) caused the high growth, while ignoring counterexamples (countries with repression but low growth, or rapid growth without repression), thus leading to a biased, misleading inference.

Why this reasoning is weak and misleading: Because the sample is conditioned on the outcome, the analysis cannot disentangle cause from coincidence. It ignores alternative explanations and the possibility that other factors correlated with growth (industrial policy, global demand, capital flows, technology transfer) drive the results, or that repression may be a result of other conditions rather than the cause of growth.

In summary, the passage exemplifies selecting on the dependent variable, a form of sampling bias that leads to incorrect causal inferences by focusing only on cases with the desired outcome and overlooking cases without it.

类似问题

Which of the biases is illustrated by the following example? A university survey about food preference of students on campus only questions students part of the nutrition program.

Which of the below types of bias were NOT mentioned in the Moodle lesson?

What was the world's first widely adopted biodiversity policy?

The aim of the Paris Agreement is to ensure that the earth’s preindustrial temperature is not exceeded by more than º Celsius.

The IPCC's mission is to Blank ______.

Why have most international agreements for environmental protection been based on the honor system?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单