What are critics of AI skeptical about its use in medicine?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks about what critics of AI are skeptical about regarding its use in medicine. 
Option 1: 'Because we trust experts because they come from reputable institutions, but AI doesn't come from a reputable institution.' This choice relies on the notion of institutional legitimacy; however, AI can be developed by organizations with strong reputations and rigorous standards, so the claim that AI inherently comes from an illegitimate source is exaggerated and ignores the reality that AI systems can be produced by credible researchers and institutions. 
Option 2: 'Because we trust experts because they can justify their reasoning to us, and AI cannot justify its reasoning.' This option highlights a key concern often raised in AI ethics and medicine: explainability and justification. Humans can provide reasoning steps and evidence for decisions, whereas AI systems may be opaque, offering outputs without transparent or easily understandable justification, which undermines trust and accountability in medical contexts. This line of reasoning aligns with widely discussed critiques about AI interpretability. 
Option 3: 'Because we trust experts because they can empathize with our situation, and AI can't empathize with us.' Empathy is indeed valuable in patient care, but AI can simulate compassionate responses or tailor interactions; the core skepticism in medicine usually emphasizes explanation and justification rather than purely emotional support. This answer captures a facet but overstates the uniqueness of empathy as a barrier, since human clinicians also establish trust and rapport through interaction. 
Option 4: 'Because we trust experts because of their years of schooling, and AI doesn't have years of schooling.' This is a shallow framing, conflating formal credentials with trust in decision-making. The issue in medicine is not just credentials but the ability to provide transparent reasoning, evidence, and validation across diverse patients and scenarios. 
Across the options, the strongest critique that maps onto a central, widely discussed concern about AI in medicine is about the ability of AI to justify its reasoning. The other options touch on related, but less central or partially inaccurate points about legitimacy, empathy, or credentials.

What are critics of AI skeptical about its use in medicine? 单项选择题

类似问题

London argues that we should integrate AI into medicine because (Check BOTH that apply)

Why is explainability especially critical when using AI systems to assist with medical diagnoses?

A 62.9 kg lady is standing on a weighing scale in an elevator as shown in the diagram below. Assume gravitational acceleration = 15 ms-2 Given that the elevator is accelerating upwards at 3.7 ms-2 , determine the magnitude of the normal force on the lady.

An object is fired from ground level at an angle of 31.9 degrees to the horizontal. Taking acceleration due to gravity = 7.65 ms-2 If the initial speed is 5.6 ms-1, how far from the starting point will it hit the ground? Assume air resistance is negligible.

Which of the following equations of motion would be used to calculate the displacement given the initial and final velocities as well as the acceleration?

A 51.8 kg lady is standing on a weighing scale (calibrated to 9.81 ms-2) in an elevator as shown in the diagram below. The scale is then calibrated to 7.67 ms-2 Given that the elevator is accelerating downwards at 2.2 ms-2 , determine the reading on the scale.

An object is fired from ground level at an angle of 39 degrees to the horizontal. Taking acceleration due to gravity = 7.65 ms-2 If the initial speed is 6.8 ms-1, how far from the starting point will it hit the ground? Assume air resistance is negligible.

Which of the following equations of motion would be used to calculate the displacement given the initial and final velocities as well as the time taken?

更多留学生实用工具

智能学习助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单