Read the following article on a recent case concerning citizenship laws in Malaysia and answer the question below: https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2022/07/24/how-malaysias-discriminatory-citizenship-laws-tore-one-family-apart/18542 According to the article, which of the following reasons BEST contributes to the issue of the overseas children not being granted citizenship in Malaysia?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Examining the question, we must identify which stated reason BEST explains why overseas children are not granted citizenship in Malaysia according to the referenced article.
Option A: 'The fact the Malaysian constitution does not allow for citizenship rights to be granted to non-citizens who were born in countries that do not have a good diplomatic relationship with Malaysia.' This is not supported by the article’s framing; the issue is structural and legal-not diplomatic relations with other countries, rather than a blanket diplomatic criterion. It mischaracterizes the legal basis and broad policy as a diplomatic fingerprint rather than a constitutional rule.
Option B: 'The fact that Article 15(2) states that the Malaysian government is to decide whether to register any person ― aged below 21 and who has at least one Malaysian parent ― as a Malaysian citizen, if the person’s parent or guardian applies for the citizenship registration, and the government has not made the decision to approve the application.' While Article 15(2) describes a discretionary process for registration, the core discriminatory challenge highlighted in the article is not merely discretionary delay, but the gender-based exclusion embedded in the relevant provision. This option points to a process feature, but it does not capture the fundamental discriminatory mechanism emphasized in the piece.
Option C: 'The fact that the children were not born in Malaysia.' While birth location can affect citizenship pathways in some contexts, the article focuses on gendered parentage rules rather than place of birth. This choice misses the central constitutional provision that creates unequal outcomes for overseas-born children depending on the parent’s gender and citizenship status.
Option D: 'The fact that the mother of the overseas children has passed away.' The article does not hinge on maternal death as the key barrier; the deprivation is tied to the statutory rule about paternal citizenship at birth. This option introduces a condition that is not presented as the central discriminatory mechanism.
Option E: 'The fact that Article 14(1)(b) requires the father (not the mother) of the children who were born overseas to be a Malaysian citizen at the time of their birth.' This directly identifies the gender-biased constitutional rule that leads to unequal treatment of children born abroad, making it the core reason the article highlights for the citizenship issue. By stipulating paternal citizenship as the qualification at birth, it creates a discriminatory path that many overseas-born children cannot meet if the father is not Malaysian at that moment, which best aligns with the article’s analysis.
In summary, each option attempts to attribute the problem to a different aspect, but only Option E pinpoints the precise constitutional mechanism described in the article as the fundamental contributor to overseas children not receiving citizenship. The other options either misstate the legal basis or emphasize factors not central to the discrimination highlighted in the piece.

Similar Questions

Question at position 1 A firm competing in a single-product market in a single geographic location does not need a corporate-level strategy regarding product diversity or an international strategy to deal with geographic diversity.TrueFalse

If marginal cost equals average cost, then what must be TRUE?

Which of the following statements is CORRECT?

Table 3 shows the short-run production costs for a car wash: [table] Costs | Cost per month ($) Land lease | 4,000 Workers’ wages | 2,600 Car wash machines | 3,000 Water | 1,500 Cleaning chemicals | 900 [/table] In the short run, calculate the car wash's fixed costs in Table 3.

Table 1 shows the change in the total output of Company C as they increase the total number of workers. Referring to Table 1 below, where does diminishing marginal returns to labour set in? Table 1 Company C’s total output

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler