Why didn't Dr. Marshall's colleagues believe that peptic ulcers could be caused by bacteria?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

To understand why Dr. Marshall's colleagues doubted a bacterial cause for peptic ulcers, we need to consider the historical beliefs about ulcer etiology.
Option 1: 'There was strong evidence that peptic ulcers are caused by eating spicy foods.' This claim reflects a common myth rather than scientific consensus; at the time, spicy foods were blamed, but there was no rigorous evidence linking them to ulcers, so this statement misstates the scientific basis.
Option 2: 'There was strong evidence that peptic ulcers are caused by high levels of stress.' Similar to spicy foods, stress was proposed as a contributing factor, but it lacked definitive causal proof; claiming strong evidence here is inaccurate and oversimplifies the debate.
Option 3: 'They did not think that bacteria could survive in the acidic environment of the stomach.' This is the core misconception. The stomach’s harsh acidity was believed to sterilize and prevent bacteria from thriving there, so bacteria were not considered viable ulcer culprits under that assumption.
Option 4: 'They did not think that bacteria could survive at body temperature.' While body temperature is compatible with bacterial life, the key issue was the stomach’s acidity, not the temperature alone; however, the prevailing belief emphasized acid resistance rather than viability at normal body temperature.
In sum, the principal reason for skepticism about a bacterial cause was the belief that the stomach’s acidic environment would prevent bacteria from surviving there, making a bacterial etiology seem implausible given the knowledge at the time.

Why didn't Dr. Marshall's colleagues believe that peptic ulcers could be caused by bacteria?Single choice

Similar Questions

Heliobacter pylori is a bacterium that affects the stomach. What effect does it have? on this organ?

Question at position 16 Which is FALSE about Helicobacter pylori:There is only one geographic typeIt is well adapted to humansIt has infected humans for thousands of yearsIt causes ulcersClear my selection

Which of the following microbe commonly causes peptic ulcer disease?

Question 30 Choose a, b, c or d as the best answer. The author’s main argument is that the 100:80:100 model __________.

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler