In Allison Eck’s article “How Music Resonates in the Brain,” Dr. Patrick Whelan’s ideas on music are discussed. On what scientific basis does Whelan attribute some of the significance of music’s power to?

Notice: The questions and answer sets for this quiz are protected under copyright, and may not be reproduced without the author's consent.

Question

In Allison Eck’s article “How Music Resonates in the Brain,” Dr. Patrick Whelan’s ideas on music are discussed. On what scientific basis does Whelan attribute some of the significance of music’s power to?

Notice: The questions and answer sets for this quiz are protected under copyright, and may not be reproduced without the author's consent.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Whelan attributes music’s power to evolutionary biology — specifically the idea that early mammals relied heavily on hearing for survival.

1. Relevant knowledge points and concepts
- Evolutionary adaptation: sensory systems evolve under survival pressures.  
- Early mammalian ecology: many early mammals were small and nocturnal, making vision less useful and hearing crucial.  
- Auditory processing and emotion: neural circuits for detecting pitch, rhythm, and prosody are ancient and tightly linked to attention and affect.

2. Step-by-step reasoning
- Early mammals lived in low-light environments where sight was limited. To avoid predators and locate prey, they depended on auditory cues.  
- This dependence favored selection for highly sensitive and specialized auditory systems (middle/inner ear structures, brainstem and cortical auditory regions).  
- Those auditory circuits became adept at detecting subtle changes in frequency, timing, and amplitude — the very features that music exploits (melody, rhythm, timbre).  
- Over evolutionary time, circuits that processed socially relevant sounds (calls, infant cries) became intertwined with emotional systems (limbic structures). Music engages these pre-existing pathways, producing strong affective responses.

3. Intermediate steps (conceptual)
- Ecological constraint (nocturnal life) → selection for acute hearing → development of neural mechanisms for sound pattern detection → music taps those mechanisms → perceived power/significance of music.

4. Why the correct answer is correct
- Whelan links music’s potency to these ancient, survival-driven auditory adaptations. The explanatory power lies in showing music is not just cultural ornament but leverages deep biological circuitry shaped by evolutionary pressures on early mammals.

5. Why other options are incorrect
- Option 1 (innate understanding of acoustics) focuses on physics, not the evolutionary origin of our sensitivity.  
- Option 3 (religious ritual) emphasizes cultural/social functions but not the biological basis Whelan stresses.  
- Option 4 (sexual attraction) is a competing hypothesis but not the primary basis Whelan highlights; he emphasizes survival-related hearing rather than mate choice.

6. Conclusion
This explanation confirms answer 2: Evolutionary biology — that early mammals had to rely heavily on hearing for survival.

Similar Questions

Recognising facial emotion is most likely to convey an evolutionary benefit because;

Expansionary fiscal policy in an open economy with a floating exchange rate will likely:

Contractionary monetary policy in an open economy with a floating exchange rate will likely:

Contractionary monetary policy in an open economy with a fixed exchange rate will likely ____ a trade surplus.

Which is expansionary monetary policy?

Which is contractionary fiscal policy?

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler